Is it the number of love scenes or the amount of space between the scenes?
I asked this question on Twitter and Facebook and I was really surprised at the difference in the answers…
” i think how descriptive/graphic the love scenes is what pushes it over that line”–@limecello
“IMHO neither. What makes a book an “erotic romance” is if the sex is an intricate part of the plot–moving it forward.. I often think too many authors think if they add certain words, that makes a book “erotic”. I don’t thinks. TOTALLY my opinion”–@JenniferLeeland
“I always heard it’s erotic if sex is a big part of the plot, rather than the offshoot of things that happen in the plot.”–@cariquinn
“I think it’s the words the author uses, what the chars are doing, and where they’re doing it.”–@RebeccaYork43
“For me, it’s the amount of love scenes, as in ~50% of book.”–@JillSorensen
“Neither, really. It’s more of how graphic it is and the use of sex as a driving plot point. Burn For Me is a very good example of this as is Love Me Knots.”–@ZoeNichols
“Or the intensity and graphic description of the love scenes?”–@Raineweaver
People really aren’t sure and that makes for a blurry line for authors. For me, who is the author I most have to worry about.
I’m editing my next erotic romance for 2010, “All Of You” and as I’m coming down the stretch, I couldn’t help but wonder…is it erotic enough to satisfy erotic audiences?
With these answers in mind, it’s hard to feel comforted. My goal is always to write a complete story, a great romance and a satisfying read. Like most other categories, there are rumored “rules”–start and end with a love scene, you must have at least 3 fully consumated sex scenes and a definite happy ending. There’s also a belief that these characters will be thinking about sex first, anything else later, so the plot must be sexually geared.
I’m still wondering though, how far those rules can be bent. If they should be rules at all. And how far outside the box do I think, when I figure a story can be erotic, romantic and it’s own unique animal?